Make your picks. Beat the host.

Take on Chuck in quick sports prediction challenges.

Play at beatchuck.com
Mike Pettine's headset can't fix the defense Christian Parker inherited cover
Back to Beat Chuck Newsroom

Mike Pettine's headset can't fix the defense Christian Parker inherited

Dallas moved defensive play-calling from coordinator Christian Parker to Mike Pettine for the rest of the season. Tank Bellamy says the Cowboys changed the one thing their own players say isn't the problem.

Share this article

  • Brian Schottenheimer took the call sheet away from Christian Parker on Wednesday and let him keep everything else, and I think he fixed the one thing his own players say isn't broken. You don't hand Sunday to a new voice while the old voice runs Monday through Saturday unless you believe the problem is the calls. The Cowboys' defensive linemen stood at their lockers the same day and said it isn't.

    Schottenheimer laid out the arrangement to ESPN. Parker, 34 and the youngest defensive coordinator in team history, keeps the title. "He's still running meetings. He's still leading walk-throughs," Schottenheimer said. "The only thing that's different is he's not calling the plays on game day." Mike Pettine, the senior assistant who came aboard before Week 5 and gave Parker his first NFL job in Green Bay in 2019, calls it the rest of the way, starting Sunday against Tennessee.

    I get why something had to give. Dallas is 4-6 and last in the league in total yards allowed, run defense and third-down defense. San Francisco hung 584 yards on them Sunday, the most the Cowboys have ever allowed in a home game. They've given up nine plays of 50 yards or more, the most in the NFL, and six of those came in the last three games. Schottenheimer said missing the playoffs would make the season a failure. With seven games left, I don't blame him for feeling the clock.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Chuck
  • Now listen to the guys who have to line up. Kenny Clark said "it's not a completely new defense" and that there's "no magic playcall" Pettine can hand them. Quinnen Williams said, "Everything is on us." When your defensive tackles volunteer that the problem is execution, I'd take them at their word. They know better than anyone whether the call was wrong or somebody just didn't get there.

    I blocked for a lot of years under a lot of coordinators, and I never once walked off the field after a long touchdown thinking about who called the play. You think about your own feet, your own angle, the guy you didn't get a hand on. A new voice in the helmet doesn't touch any of that.

    The streak tells you this didn't start with Parker, either. Dallas has allowed more than 20 points in 17 straight games across two seasons. Ten of those are this year. The other seven belong to a defense that finished 2025 ranked 30th and gave up 511 points, which is why the Cowboys went through nine candidates before hiring Parker in January. Since then they've signed Jalen Thompson, traded for Rashan Gary and Joey Porter Jr., and drafted Caleb Downs and Malachi Lawrence in the first round. None of that lives on a play sheet.

  • The best case for the move is a fair one. Pettine has run defenses for the Jets, Bills and Packers, and a man who's done it that long might just handle third-and-7 better than a first-year coordinator. If Dallas gets off the field on third down against Tennessee, I'll say so here.

    What bugs me is that this is half a demotion, handed to a coach Schottenheimer insists has a bright future. Downs said the news hurt his heart. Clark said he was "bummed." Those players still sit in Parker's meetings every morning and then hear someone else on Sunday. If Schottenheimer thought the calls were the problem, Pettine should have the job outright. If he believes in Parker, Parker should get to call his way out of this. Splitting the difference means nobody is accountable until January.

    So here's my end of it. If Pettine calls seven games and the Cowboys still give up 20-plus most weeks, which is my guess, then the headset was never the problem, and the people who built this roster owe Parker his call sheet back before anyone grades him.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.