
Tennessee beat Alabama by 16, and the CFP committee still ranks the Tide six spots higher
Alabama held at No. 3 in Tuesday's CFP rankings while 8-2 Tennessee, which beat the Tide 26-10 in October, slid to ninth. Dex Malone says the committee keeps overruling the one result that settles it.
By Dex Malone, The Beat / 2 sources / Published November 18, 2026
Tennessee and Alabama have the same record. Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10. And in Tuesday night's College Football Playoff rankings, Alabama is third with a first-round bye while Tennessee is ninth. The committee can wrap that in all the strength-of-schedule language it likes, and it used plenty, but the scoreboard settled this on Oct. 17 and the committee keeps overruling it.
That game wasn't a lucky bounce at the end. The Vols outgained Alabama 347 yards to 201 in Knoxville, per the Knoxville News Sentinel. Keelon Russell turned it over three times, got sacked five times and threw for 147 yards, and Alabama converted 2 of 13 third downs. Call it what it was, one team pushing the other around for four quarters.
Committee chair Hunter Yurachek told ESPN's Rece Davis that the room "feels very high on Tennessee," and that the Vols "wouldn't be ranked ninth if we didn't think highly of them as a committee." Fine. Then think highly enough to put them next to the team they beat. Last week the gap was five spots, and the explanation was that Alabama sat in a stronger first "pool" of teams on schedule strength. This week Tennessee went on the road and won at Texas A&M, and the gap got bigger.
Free to play
Make your call with Beat Chuck
Check the challenge board for the latest open games.
All Beat Chuck games →
Last week I wrote that the committee punished Indiana for a bye week, dropping the Hoosiers from fourth to ninth while their old opponents lost. Then this past weekend South Carolina, LSU, Kentucky and Mississippi State, the wins that prop up Alabama's résumé, all lost too. Alabama didn't move an inch. Yurachek's answer was that the losses "didn't have the same impact on their strength of schedule that it had on Indiana's strength of schedule." Maybe that's what the private numbers say. I can't check them and neither can you, which is sort of the whole problem.
I'll give the other side its due, because it has a real case. Tennessee isn't a juggernaut. Yurachek said everyone in the room sees the Vols "as being a defensive-oriented team first and offense second," and the Sentinel has them 38th in relative scoring offense. Tennessee also lost to Texas, which now sits fifth. Alabama won at LSU 31-13 earlier this month, and Yurachek said it's won its six SEC games by an average of 22.5 points. If you told me Alabama would beat Tennessee on a neutral field in December, I wouldn't laugh you out of the room.
But that's a guess, and 26-10 is a result. Two teams with two losses each, one of them beat the other by 16, and the committee's case for the loser comes down to everything except the afternoon they actually shared a field. Yurachek said that when the committee watches Alabama, "we really feel like (Alabama is) one of the 3-4 best teams in the country." I'd start the film session with the game where Alabama gained 201 yards. It's the only one on the tape against Tennessee.
I'm not claiming a perfect record on this committee, either. I said ninth might be about right for Indiana, and the Hoosiers are eighth now after a real win over USC. So I'm not asking for Tennessee at No. 3. My ask is smaller and harder to argue with. Put the Vols one spot above the team they beat, wherever the committee wants Alabama to live, and let the bye fall where it falls after that. If the committee can't do that by Selection Sunday, it should quit saying it thinks highly of Tennessee, because the only spot in these rankings that matters for that argument says otherwise.
Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.
More from Beat Chuck Newsroom
Related stories
FootballFive things to watch in tonight's CFP rankings, starting with whether Texas passes Alabama
FootballSports TV schedule for Nov. 17 to 23: Feast Week, CFP rankings and Vikings-49ers in Mexico City
NBAMonday's five best NBA performances: Donovan Mitchell's 39 against Chicago tops the list
College BasketballChuck Hot 10: Florida stays No. 1, and Michigan State jumps five spots after winning at Duke