Make your picks. Beat the host.

Take on Chuck in quick sports prediction challenges.

Play at beatchuck.com
Nobody should tell Aidan Hutchinson he got hurt because he celebrated cover
Back to Beat Chuck Newsroom

Nobody should tell Aidan Hutchinson he got hurt because he celebrated

Aidan Hutchinson's season looks over after his knee gave out as he celebrated a sack of Drake Maye in Munich. Tank Bellamy says the jump was the job, and the lesson isn't to stop doing it.

Share this article

  • I'll say this before somebody with a microphone says the opposite. Aidan Hutchinson didn't do anything wrong when he jumped, and nobody should walk away from Munich thinking the lesson is to quit celebrating sacks.

    The facts are ugly enough without a lecture. Hutchinson sacked Drake Maye on third down on New England's first drive Sunday, leaped to celebrate and went straight to the ground when he landed, grabbing his right knee. Sources told NFL Network's Ian Rapoport that initial tests showed a torn ACL, with concern about the meniscus. ESPN's Adam Schefter posted Monday that the Lions fear it's season-ending, though the team has declined to confirm it. The same sack left the Patriots fearing Maye fractured his ankle. Detroit won 35-10 for its fifth straight and lost its best pass rusher doing it.

    I get the instinct. A guy gets hurt on a play he made, not one made against him, and it looks avoidable. If he just gets up and jogs back to the huddle, he's fine, right? I've heard some version of that after every freak injury I can remember. I've probably said it myself from a couch.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Chuck
  • It's still wrong, and I can tell you why from the wrong side of it. I spent my whole career trying to keep guys like Hutchinson off my quarterback. When one got past me and jumped, I hated it. I also never once thought he should stop. That jump is the job finishing. Third down, offense's first drive, crowd on its feet. A defensive end who makes that play and walks back like he's filing paperwork is a defensive end who's stopped playing the way that got him there.

    And the jump isn't special. Knees go on jump balls, on blocks, on a plant in bad turf. Football asks you to land on one leg a hundred times a game. Hutchinson has 49 sacks since Detroit took him second overall in 2022, per ESPN. That's 49 times he did the hardest thing his position asks, and one time the landing went wrong.

    Lions fans are allowed to wince harder than anybody. Rapoport noted it's the second time in three seasons Hutchinson's year looks likely to end early, and that stings in a way no ruling fixes.

  • If you want something to argue about, argue about the tackle, and you'll lose that one too. Walt Anderson, the league's officiating rules analyst, said through a spokesman that it wasn't a hip-drop because there was no swivel or unweighting. Mike Vrabel, whose quarterback was on the bottom of the pile, said, "I don't think it was anything intentional. It's just part of the game." When the coach who lost his starter won't hunt for a villain, the rest of us don't need to invent one.

    So leave the jump alone. Every pass rusher I ever failed to block did some version of it, and I'd have been embarrassed for them if they hadn't.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.