Make your picks. Beat the host.

Take on Chuck in quick sports prediction challenges.

Play at beatchuck.com
Laugh at Dustin May's 4.70 ERA if you want. The White Sox were right to pay him $52.5 million cover
Back to Beat Chuck Newsroom

Laugh at Dustin May's 4.70 ERA if you want. The White Sox were right to pay him $52.5 million

The White Sox gave Dustin May three years and $52.5 million after a 4.70 ERA and a rough October in Milwaukee. Chuck says a rotation that threw the fewest innings in baseball needed exactly what May finally delivered.

Share this article

  • I've judged pitchers by their ERA for most of my life, and ten years ago I'd have laughed at this deal. The White Sox agreed Tuesday to pay Dustin May $52.5 million over three years, coming off a 4.70 ERA. I'm not laughing. Chicago paid for the thing it was shortest on, and May just had the busiest season of his career.

    Start with the hole. ESPN reported that the White Sox rotation threw a major league-low 674 2/3 innings this season, and that the club ran out of pitching during its surprise playoff run. CBS Sports counted two traditional starters in Chicago's seven postseason games. The rest were openers and bullpen games. That's a clever way to survive June. In October it means asking relievers to cover innings that starters are supposed to cover.

    Now look at what May did. He made a career-high 31 starts and threw 145 2/3 innings between St. Louis and Milwaukee. For a pitcher who missed all of 2024 after a second Tommy John surgery and an esophageal tear, that's the line on the résumé that matters most. His fastball averaged 96.9 mph, 15th among the 141 pitchers who threw at least 100 innings, per CBS. And the 4.70 came with a 3.63 FIP, so the walks, strikeouts and homers looked a good deal better than the runs did.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Chuck
  • The case against him is real, and I'll give it its full due. After the deadline trade he had a 5.65 ERA in 10 starts for the Brewers, and the Sun-Times noted he allowed seven earned runs in 11 postseason innings, including a three-run homer to Shohei Ohtani in the NLCS. His ERA over the last two seasons is 4.82. MLB Trade Rumors pointed out that four previous clubs tried to pull more out of that arm with "minimal success," and that's a fair summary.

    None of that touches Chicago's actual problem, though. Nobody is signing May to start Game 1 of a playoff series, and ESPN was honest that he's not necessarily a top-of-the-rotation arm. He's there so Sean Burke, Anthony Kay and Davis Martin aren't the whole plan, and so Noah Schultz and Grant Taylor can earn starts instead of getting shoved into them. A guy who takes the ball every fifth day changes how a manager burns his bullpen in August, and that decides what the bullpen has left in October.

    The money doesn't scare me for this club, either. The White Sox finished 2026 with a $98.93 million payroll, according to MLB Trade Rumors, a long way from the $193 million they spent in 2022. The Sun-Times called it the franchise's largest free-agent outlay since Andrew Benintendi in 2023. ESPN noted the Sox finished near the top of the league in offense, so if a team that just made the playoffs on spare parts is finally going to spend, I'd much rather it go to the rotation than to another bat.

  • Where I'd worry is the third year. Two healthy seasons in a row is progress. Three more is a bet on an elbow that's been rebuilt twice, and the deal is still pending a physical, according to his agent. If May is back on the injured list by 2028, I'll take my lumps on this one, and my editor will enjoy reminding me.

    So here's my dare. If May hands Chicago 30 starts next year with an ERA somewhere in the mid-fours, the folks laughing at that 4.70 on Tuesday should come find me and explain why it was a bad contract. I'll be in the press box, and I'm not expecting a line.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.