Make your picks. Beat the host.

Take on Chuck in quick sports prediction challenges.

Play at beatchuck.com
Joe Burrow's Peyton Manning streak is the least important thing he did to Pittsburgh cover
Back to Beat Chuck Newsroom

Joe Burrow's Peyton Manning streak is the least important thing he did to Pittsburgh

Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards and four touchdowns as the Bengals beat the Steelers 38-18 and moved a game clear in the AFC North. Dex Malone says the record-book stat is the sideshow and the standings are the story.

Share this article

  • By Monday morning you'd seen the graphic. Joe Burrow is the second quarterback ever with four or more total touchdowns in five straight games, and the other one is Peyton Manning, who won MVP the year he did it. Lovely graphic. It's also the least important thing that happened in Cincinnati on Sunday night.

    The important thing is the AFC North. The Bengals and Steelers both walked into Paycor Stadium at 6-2. Cincinnati walked out 7-2 after a 38-18 win, and Pittsburgh walked out a game back. Beating the team you're tied with in the middle of November is about as good as a regular-season win gets, and it's the kind that tends to come up again when the tiebreakers get sorted out in January.

    I know the counter, and it's a fair one. The 409 yards are how they got to 38. Burrow went 35 of 44 with four touchdowns and no interceptions, per ESPN's box score, and he had 302 yards and three scores by halftime. Ja'Marr Chase caught 11 balls for 231 yards. At one point Underdog NFL had Burrow at 243 passing yards and Aaron Rodgers at zero. I'm not pretending that was anything less than a quarterback taking a defense apart.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Chuck
  • But here's what the streak can't tell you. Five straight games of four-plus touchdowns says Burrow's hot. It says nothing about whether this team wins the night he throws for 190, and that's the night that decides divisions. Pittsburgh finished with 222 total yards. Rodgers threw both of his touchdowns in the fourth quarter after Cincinnati was already up 31-3, and Joe Flacco finished the game for the Bengals. That wasn't a shootout Burrow had to win. The Steelers never made it one, which says as much about Pittsburgh's offense as it does about him.

    So my problem isn't with Burrow. It's with what we do with numbers like these. We turn them into an MVP case by Tuesday, and then a 23-20 grind in December gets graded as a "down game" when it's the more useful win. The Manning comparison is fun because it's a record-book argument, and record-book arguments don't require anybody to look at the standings.

    Look at them anyway. A one-game lead with Pittsburgh at 6-3 and Cleveland at 6-4 is a lead you can lose in a week. Cincinnati plays at Washington next Monday night, Nov. 23, and that's the game I care about. If Burrow throws for 230 and one touchdown and the Bengals win by four, the streak ends, the graphic goes away, and I'll like that win more than this one. Here's my dare to the MVP crowd: cheer that one as loud as you cheered Sunday.

  • Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.