Make your picks. Beat the host.

Take on Chuck in quick sports prediction challenges.

Play at beatchuck.com
Don't let MLB's slick salary cap video sell you the lockout cover
Back to Beat Chuck Newsroom

Don't let MLB's slick salary cap video sell you the lockout

MLB released a five-minute video pitching fans on a hard salary cap and floor, with its labor deal expiring Dec. 1 and a lockout widely expected. Dex Malone says the ad leaves out the parts fans would hate.

Share this article

  • MLB made you a commercial. It runs five minutes, it's pinned to the league's X account, and its job is to get you on the owners' side before they lock the players out. Don't sign up.

    The pitch, straight from the league's Nov. 13 post: split all revenue 50/50 with the players, put in a salary cap and a floor, and share media money equally among the 30 clubs. The league says that helps fix local blackouts, that player pay goes up, and that "It's a win for everybody." Front Office Sports reported Monday that the video stars Morgan Sword, MLB's executive vice president of baseball operations, as part of a "Level the Playing Field" campaign, and that it's past 1.7 million impressions.

    I'll give the league its best point first, because it's a good one. Blackouts are awful, fans have hated them for years, and pooling local media money is at least a real attempt at a fix. Sword also has a line that lands. He says it's hard to buy tickets or a jersey when you feel like your favorite player is going to end up in New York or L.A. one day. Plenty of fans in smaller markets know exactly what he means.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Chuck
  • Now read what FOS says isn't in the video. Limits on the size and length of free-agent contracts. New restrictions on signing bonuses and entry rules for drafted players. Those are cuts the owners want at the table, and the five-minute case for fairness never gets around to them. If your plan really is a win for everybody, you put all of it on screen. You don't skip the part where the contracts get shorter.

    The timing does the rest of the talking. The labor deal expires Dec. 1, FOS calls a lockout widely expected, and ESPN's Jeff Passan was already writing last week about a lockout-induced transaction freeze. Once it hits, all player transactions stop. A league that liked its chances at the bargaining table wouldn't spend the last two weeks before that buying your sympathy. You make this kind of video when you want the public to blame the other side once the doors are locked.

    The sport keeps getting in MLB's way, too. Milwaukee, the smallest media market in baseball, just won the World Series with the No. 19 payroll. The league told FOS it's looking at longer-term trends instead. Fine, make that case to the people who have to sign the deal. Jameson Taillon, a free agent who used to sit on the union's executive subcommittee, called the video "comically bad" and said owners "want to drive down salaries." You don't have to buy all of that to see the obvious problem: the players are the one audience an ad can't move.

  • So here's my dare. If this is about fans, MLB should pull the blackout fix out and offer it on its own, cap or no cap. Fans would take that deal tomorrow. If the answer is that blackouts only get fixed once the players swallow a cap, then the video was never about blackouts, and you just sat through the owners' opening offer with better lighting.

    Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.