
Benching Daniel Jones now just gives Anthony Richardson a free audition for his next team
Shane Steichen said the Colts will "evaluate everything" after Daniel Jones was pulled in a 26-3 loss at Houston. Dex Malone says benching Jones mostly helps whoever signs Richardson in free agency.
By Dex Malone, The Beat / 1 source / Published November 20, 2026
Bench Daniel Jones now and the Colts are running a free tryout for whichever team signs Anthony Richardson in March. That's the whole case. I'm not defending Jones. I'm saying the move everybody's screaming for helps somebody else.
You saw Thursday. Houston won 26-3, Jones went 12 of 27 for 144 yards and an interception, and Shane Steichen pulled him halfway through the fourth quarter down 23. Asked if Jones was still his starter, Steichen said the Colts would "evaluate everything."
He said that before. After the 42-7 loss in Jacksonville in Week 8, Colts.com noted, he promised to evaluate everything, and a day later he stuck with Jones. So, fine, this time he means it. Let's evaluate.
Free to play
Make your call with Beat Chuck
Check the challenge board for the latest open games.
All Beat Chuck games →
Jones is bad right now. I'll give you the worst of it. Among 31 qualifying quarterbacks, theScore had him 30th in EPA per dropback and dead last in passer rating, and UPI counted a league-high 13 interceptions. Nobody watching that offense convert 1 of 11 third downs is calling it a supporting-cast problem and nothing else.
Now look at what the Colts put around him. Since that Jacksonville game they traded Keenan Allen and Josh Downs, their top two receivers. On Thursday they were missing both starting tackles, Bernhard Raimann and Jalen Travis, against Will Anderson Jr., who sacked Jones for a safety. You can drop any quarterback into that and he's going to look like he's throwing underwater. Richardson included.
And here's the part that should bother Indy fans. Richardson is in the last year of his rookie deal. The Colts declined his fifth-year option in April, he asked for a trade last offseason, and theScore says he's headed for unrestricted free agency. So every good Sunday he has from here raises his price, mostly for the 31 teams that didn't spend four years waiting on him. Could the Colts re-sign him? Sure. They had the chance to lock in a fifth year in April and passed.
Jones is the opposite. He signed a two-year, $88 million deal in March, so he's on the payroll next season whether Steichen likes his tape or not. If the Colts want to learn anything useful in these last six games, it's whether Jones can play in this offense with real tackles in front of him. You don't learn that from the bench.
There isn't even a tanking prize. theScore notes the Colts don't own their 2027 first-round pick. At 3-8 they can't lose their way to a better draft slot. Bench the vet and all you're doing is trading a lost season for a press release.
Steichen said the quiet part himself. "I'm the play caller. I'm in charge of all of it, so I got to do a better job calling plays." That's the guy holding the call sheet for an offense that's been outscored 68-10 in its two division road games, per Colts.com. I'd start the evaluation there.
My colleague Chuck wrote three weeks ago that the Colts should just start Richardson. If they do it and he lights up the Giants, I'll hear about it in the group chat for a month. I'll take that risk. Paying Jones to sit and watch a free agent audition is worse.
Our columnists are fictional characters written with AI. The facts come from the reported stories linked here.
More from Beat Chuck Newsroom
Related stories
The BeatThe Colts got nothing for Daniel Jones because they hung up on Minnesota and Baltimore
FootballThe Colts release Daniel Jones a day after the 26-3 loss in Houston and make Anthony Richardson Sr. the starter
NBAAlperen Sengun is questionable with a scratched cornea as the Rockets visit Jokic and the Nuggets in the NBA Cup
FootballTale of the tape: No. 13 Oregon chases its first win at Spartan Stadium as Michigan State runs short on quarterbacks